Sunday, August 13, 2023

draft of a review of a Don Walker album from August 2013

I wrote this bunch of cliches and almost thought I'd written a record review, then realised, fuck this is poor. So you can read it ten years later OK.


Don Walker
Hully Gully

Sometimes the smart thing to do would seem to be to wait before passing judgment, and in the case of a new Don Walker album I would like to take about five years just to be sure. Of course that doesn’t suit the people who paid for/released the record, or the people who promote the shows to promote the record, or the artist himself I would imagine. Certainly all of them could validly point out that, considering Walker’s last solo album Cutting Back – released in 2006 – remains one of my favourite albums of the 21st century, it’d be at very least contrary to be finicky about passing judgment on this one. So, of course, I will naturally concede that this one’s already got me in its grasp, and after only a few quick and cursory listens I can tell that it’s a doozy, perhaps more pop (perhaps more facile, or maybe just less miserable) than Cutting Back, but still brilliant.

I don’t especially buy into Walker’s various mythologies; to a certain degree I think they are a front that keep him away from writing about his true self – caveat being that anything other than a very abstracted version of his true self wouldn’t really connect with anyone, and he’s probably right. His true self is a respected and moneyed songwriter who surely has no need to ever work again – a million miles from, for instance, the drifter protagonist in his song ‘Young Girls’ or most of the other narrators in his songs. For all that, there is no particular reason why a great songwriter should write about his ‘true self’ – who cares and why would they? – anymore than a novelist should always write autobiographically. It’s part of the weirdness of the Australian class system that Walker, an artist with working class origins, made his fortune and his name writing Cold Chisel hits which remain the soundtrack to umpteen working class Australian lives and gave everyday Australians icons like Barnesy, continues to write about people he cannot know anymore if he ever really did, (and in fact who are probably by and large a fiction now if they ever really existed) but now for a slender portion of the public. Don Walker is too weird for most people!

It’s funny also how Walker is genuinely one of the great lyricists of our time, but how often his music doesn’t come close to the brilliance of the words – you can imagine this may well be deliberate (not only does flashy music get in the way of great lyrics, but it would also intrude on the laconic and/or even-tempered and/or suppressed rage of the various stories told).  The way Walker sings is a counterpoint to that. It’s a natural voice, unusual for a singer, a bit nasal, just slightly higher than you might have imagined, but completely appropriate to the disappointed middle-aged man tales within. (Exceptions to both of these include the title track and the marvelous mid-paced ‘On the Beach’).

[END] 

No comments:

what a relief

 From Farrago 21 March 1958 p. 3. A few weeks later (11 April) Farrago reported that the bas-relief was removed ('and smashed in the pro...